…you hear a step on the stair, and it must be them; the phone rings, and you’re sure you’re going to hear their voice at the other end. It’s their being dead that you have to talk yourself into. But, of course, if the person actually were there on the stair or the phone, you’d conclude pretty quickly that you were just imagining it – you hoped for it so much that you briefly thought that your hope was reality. And I’m not sure your feeling would be all joy; there would probably be plenty of fear mixed in too…
So when Jesus does show up, after being dead, his reassurance is homely and clear, and entirely like Luke (for whom eating and drinking is the best part of life): he has a snack. We’ve seen it before… This story is the continuation of the story of the walk to Emmaus, where 2 disciples meet him along the way and tell him – they think he’s a stranger – how sad they are about losing their best friend and the best candidate so far for being Israel’s Messiah. But he responds by showing them how the Scriptures prophesy a Messiah who has to suffer and die, making his story not failure but fulfillment. ‘Didn’t you know?’ he says to them as if they were just a little dim; and they’re so shocked at what they’re hearing that they invite him in to have supper with him. And when he presides at the meal and breaks the bread for them all, then, it says, their eyes were opened and they saw who he was.
They dash back to Jerusalem to say that they had seen the Lord – and when they get together with the others, Jesus shows up again. This time he does the eating first, then opens their minds to understand that this is how it had to be. The Messiah is not about power and glory, he says, but about humility, suffering for the sake of others, prayer so deep it makes you sweat blood, dying to even your own best dreams when God’s purposes seem to require it. ‘Didn’t you know..? ‘ he says… Well, yes, we did, sort of, but we also forget all the time and need reminding…. Even after we’ve heard all the stories about the risen Lord, we still need reminding. That’s why we show up here week after week, to hear the stories, and get our minds opened, and try to learn to be the community he talks about, the community of witness to all of it.
Now of course there’s a problem with all this: we’re supposed to believe these stories because somebody wrote them down in a book; and we’re supposed to believe what’s in the book because the book says you should… But what kind of weight can that possibly carry? – it’s just circular reasoning: People aren’t that gullible – or shouldn’t be. ‘Faith’ isn’t supposed to mean believing something in spite of common sense and reason – it’s supposed to make sense. Well, what can we say, then, that might be convincing? People today are in the same spot as these disciples – they’ll be convinced by seeing, hearing, touching the risen Lord. And where can you do that? The answer is, as I’ve said so often, in the church. The church is that community in which the risen Lord may be seen – or at least that community in which the risen Lord is supposed to be able to be seen; and if he isn’t, then that community is not being the church.
So how do we make the risen Lord present in our community? Three signs stand out in these stories. One is joy, that joy that can hardly believe what it’s seeing, the joy of being given your heart’s desire just when you’d given up all hope of getting it. A community that is trying to operate as a church, but is not rooted in joy, is never going to get off the ground. It’s a get-it-or-forget-it proposition, and it operates at all levels, from the most exalted spiritual states to just plain fun. Our worship, our interaction with each other, our response to the great events of our lives, even the tragic ones, has to be marked by a deep joy – and one of the questions that Natural Church Development asks churches for self-assessment is: Are people in your church having fun?
But a second sign of the presence of the risen Lord among his friends is that unmistakeable weirdness of his appearing. The community that welcomes him is joyful, but it’s not precisely comfortable about it. There’s nothing domesticated and taken-for-granted about the Lord’s presence; it’s always a little wild, a little not under our control. It seems to me that Christians ought always to be a little off-balance – those opened minds always letting in just a little more than they can sit easy to. We’re about to get a lesson in that today, as my friend Megan talks to the Bishop’s Committee about her work with human trafficking. Who would want to know about this? – but how can a Christian community ignore it? So the resurrection community always needs to be humble too, not so terribly sure they’re right that they shut out other people’s witness. So we strive to let our minds be opened by the Scriptures given us by the risen Lord, and hearts opened by his presence among us at our shared meal, and pray that the witness of our life together might be enough for people to see it and want to be part of it.
And the third sign of the Easter people deals with our failures, what we do wrong as we live our common and individual lives. Both Luke’s and John’s resurrection stories emphasise the element of sin, the evil we do, the good that we leave undone. That’s why these stories include words about repentance, about forgiveness. These words aren’t the first words we hear – and they can’t be the first words of our witness either – because they won’t get heard. Nobody younger than my generation has grown up in the culture of guilt and shame that all previous generations in this culture were raised in. Whatever their concerns are, sin isn’t one of the big ones. The church can’t speak this language and expect the kind of response people once had to the command to ‘Repent!’ – most people who hear it won’t know what we’re talking about. Which doesn’t mean, of course, that sin is a thing of the past. People are just as greedy and foolish and cruel as they’ve always been, and corporate sin – the sin of nations, corporations, ethnic and social groups – has reached depths of evil never known before. If Monsanto and Dow succeed in killing all the bees, and the oil and coal companies succeed in persuading us all to keep right on burning up their products instead of developing alternatives, it won’t be 6 million Jews, or how many thousands of Middle-Easterners who will die, it will be all of us, and the whole earth. No, sin hasn’t gone away; it’s flourishing, but in forms we aren’t used to acknowledging.
Which means that the church’s witness has to take a new form – and it couldn’t do better than the form Jesus himself used. It’s a way of approaching judgement and repentance that works almost backwards from how we’re used to thinking of it – not condemnation, leading to repentance, leading to forgiveness, but the certainty of forgiveness leading to awareness of sin, leading to repentance. When people experience the love of God for them, they also begin to experience the places where their own lives don’t measure up to it – the places where they hold back, not giving as they have been given to; the places where their minds and hearts are not open, imprisoned, the places where they’re hanging on to grudges, resentment, delusions of grandeur, greed (the besetting sin of our time), stupidity, cruelty…. If we’re going to condemn ourselves or others, or the giant entities that need to be called to judgement in our day, we need to bear that witness from a context that gives it power. We therefore need to create a community so full of the love of the risen Lord for us, and ours for him and each other, that repentance becomes both understandable and possible.
When people experience all these things – the joy, the weirdness, the judgement – among those who have met the risen Lord, not just in stories in an old book, but in ordinary experience, in shared meals, in friendship, then they can begin the slow growth of trust that such things are possible – because they receive the assurance of being loved and a foretaste of being forgiven. And then they are empowered for service of others. That’s where the risen Lord is to be met today; that’s where we can expect that others who meet us can meet him. And so we identify the ‘program’ for this church. The joy is here; and the sense of being a little off-balance, a little not under our own control. The invitation is here, to open minds, open hearts, repentance. If witnessing to what we have been given isn’t possible here, where in heaven’s name could it happen?
The risen Lord is among us, the Lamb’s high feast is set for us – all we have to do is be so set, ourselves, to serve each other, so set to love as we have been loved, that word of what goes on here begins to get out to the world beyond our walls. We have begun to ‘shine’; and we can get better at shining up each other – as we see Jesus doing on Maundy Thursday – for the banquet to which we are all invited, until the shine dazzles those outside. That’s the witness Jesus calls us to: ‘You shall be my witnesses’. I don’t know about you, but I can’t imagine looking the risen Lord in the eye and saying, ‘No, I don’t think so’. The joy, the surprise, the generosity of the common life of this Easter-people is a message just waiting to be dellivered to the world. Pray for it, and for your own part in it.