…A young man makes some bad choices and goes astray, and, once he comes to his senses and tries to go back to the strait and narrow, his father welcomes him with open arms and throws a big party, and everything is all right again – a great story with a happy ending, and one we can all identify with, at least those of us who have ever made a bad choice and longed for somebody to take us back and make it all right again. That’s part of the story, for sure – the part that follows the parables of the lost coin and the lost sheep just before it in Luke’s Gospel, the part that the ‘tax collectors and sinners’ who mobbed Jesus’s preaching were hoping to hear. The housewife who searches high and low for her coin and the shepherd who leaves all the rest of the flock to go and find the lost one are just like the father in this parable, who longs to get his boy back and rejoices when he does. All that is told in the first column on the insert to your bulletin.
But this story is much more complicated than the other 2. They each have just one character – a housewife, a shepherd, looking for something they lost. This time what’s lost is also a character (you can’t really call a coin or a sheep a ‘character’..) with a mind of his own. And there is another character besides the seeker and the lost – there’s an older brother who has plenty of agenda of his own. His story is what’s told in the other column, reading upwards from the bottom. I gave you the insert, constructed this way, so that we could all see clearly how striking the structure of Luke’s parables is, how tightly organised they are. If you printed this out in 2 columns from start to end and drew lines to the parts that match in both columns, you’d have a big X between them, the Greek letter chi, which leads scholars to call them ‘chiastic’. You don’t have to know that word for the final exam in this course, but it’s a useful thing to know about, because parables are slippery items, and it’s often hard to know just how to take them, how to find our what they are really about. So if you have a clue that shows you where the center of the story is, you have a better chance of figuring out what the central meaning is. When you read this story in the context of Luke’s Gospel, it’s pretty obvious what that center is: the mercy of the father, which is so like the mercy of God – and, lo and behold, that’s what is right in the center of the diagram. The story knits itself together right up to that point, and then it unravels in perfect parallels, point by point. The scheme shows you how to look at Jesus’s parables in a new way: by comparing the 2 columns you see a lot of things you might have missed without it. It’s like a little drama in five acts.
Act I: There was a man who had 2 sons – that’s how the story begins. How it ends we don’t know – across from it, we find one son, inside at the party, accepted back into the family and the father’s love – and one son outside, wanting no part of either the party or the love. Makes you see the ‘point’ of the parable in a different light, doesn’t it? Almost as if the story of the younger son were just a preface to the other story, of the older brother. He ends up to be where the real action is – he and his righteousness and his stubborn-ness in anger and envy and pride, the deadliest of the deadly sins. ‘But I thought he was the good son’ – I can hear you thinking that; he certainly thinks that. But is he?
On to the next act: the younger son wants his inheritance, wants to leave home. Understandable, we think – but think again. To ask for your inheritance while your father is still alive is a terrible thing – probably about as terrible as to imagine your father as a slavedriver all the time you’re working for him. Look at our 2 scenes: one son dishonors the father by wishing he were dead; the other dishonors the father twice – first by going along with the kid’s scheme instead of defending the family honor (and why not, when it enables him to ‘inherit’ his 2/3 of the property early too?) and then further wounds it by refusing his proper place at the party, at the father’s right hand. He says he’s worked like a slave for the father – but he’s been work-ing on what is now his own property, which he was always going to inherit anyway, and his father has now given to him before it was due. The second son seems to hate his father; the first son seems to hate both his father and his brother. How does he know how the kid lost all his money? All he can feel is jealousy and hurt pride. He calls his brother ‘this son of yours’, not ‘this brother of mine’ – it’s the father who has to remind him that he has a brother. There’s not much to recommend the ‘good’ son in that scene!
Act 3 – the insides of the 2 boys. The younger one is desperate, starving; he’s come to the end of his rope. There’s no food in sight; he has no choice but to go home. The parallel part of his brother’s story shows him at the doorstep of a huge party, featuring the fatted calf, the epitome of extravagance (you could let this animal turn into 5 times as much meat if you just left it alone for a few months), and he does have a choice – to go in or stay out – and he won’t go in because he’s angry. If you see that in the context of this parable’s audience – the ‘sinners’ on the one hand and the ‘righteous’ people on the other – Jesus seems to be portraying the tax collectors and sinners as people who are where they are because they’re desperate (which, as we know from ancient and modern history, is largely true), not because they wanted to be wicked; and the so-called righteous folks as too self-righteous to know when they’re well-off. They too are invited to go in and eat some of that fatted calf – they’re not being left out of anything – but their pride and envy, their resentment of the Father’s kindness – won’t let them do it. They starve out of their own perversity. And still the father is kind; still the invitation is extended – ‘you are always with me and everything I have is yours’. What’s wrong with people who don’t see such abundance, such lavish kindness, when it’s right in front of them?
Act 4 is all about other ways of evading the kindness – the younger boy’s plan to keep clear of it – and the father’s response. The kid plans his pretty speech so that it will sound good – repentance, humility, insistence on what he doesn’t deserve (to be a son, to be part of the family). But the effect of the plan would be to let the kid earn some money of his own, now that he doesn’t have any more, and live somewhere besides the family home, on his own. ‘Treat me like one of your hired hands’ – that’s what that means. If the older son thinks of himself as one of the household slaves, the younger one wants to be a hired hand – nobody in this family wants to be what they really are, sons of the father who belong within the family, not among either slaves or hired hands. For the younger, this option is simply overridden: the father grabs him (possibly before the rest of the village can get their hands on him and beat him up or even kill him for the dishonor he’s offered to them), drags him back into the family, dresses him up with the robe and the ring and the shoes, in case there was any doubt about his being restored to his former position. His plan is shot, his status is what it’s supposed to be; he’s back living on the mercy of the father whether he wants to be or not. He had to take whatever was on offer, and this was it. The older son, not being desperate, is the one with the choice, and all the rest of the story is how he goes about making that choice.
Which brings us to the center, which we’ve approached from both ends – the compassion of the father, the love of the father for both his children that never gives up, never stops seeking, never stops inviting them into the family embrace. Calling this story ‘the prodigal son’ is a misnomer – there are 2 sons here, and the prodigal character, the wasteful one, in the story is the father. The kid just threw away all his money; the father throws away everything in the interests of these ungrateful kids. When he tells the older one that everything he has is his, he’s just telling the truth – he’s given it all away, property, honor, love, respect, any way to make a living for himself at all. The story starts with one boy wishing the old man were dead, and it ends with him as good as dead, thrown upon the mercy of 2 ungrateful kids who can now pretty much do whatever they want with him.
A colleague and I used this parable as the centerpiece of the children’s camp curriculum, 30 years ago. We sensed that it was the right thing to use, but we didn’t quite know why – I remember asking, ‘But Rob, where’s the cross in all this? We have the father’s love, the children’s disobedience, but who pays the price for that?’ I was naïve then – I hadn’t reckoned with what it costs the father to behave as he does. Now I see, and we can all see, that the parable is a story not nearly so much about 2 bad sons as a story about a father who is prepared to pay any price to keep them in his love, and the excuses, lies and sheer perversity they use to refuse his invitation. No one gets off easy in it – the children shown up as hypocrites condemned by their own ingratitude, the father condemned by that to suffer in their behalf. It’s good reading for Lent – it speaks right to us who wander and kid ourselves about the reasons for that, and to us who kid ourselves about what we deserve and resent those who seem to receive without deserving. It puts us all in the right context: as disobedient children of one father, blinded by our illusions and our greed, brothers and sisters of people we don’t even like to think about, let alone love.
The question the parable leaves us with is a question to us, the ‘good’ sons and daughters, the ones who came to church today and spend the rest of our time trying to do things right – work that often does feel like ‘slaving away’ for very little gain. The situation we’re in is pretty clear: somebody has come back from the dead and the party is in full swing. We’ve been invited, strenuously, but so have a lot of other people we would rather not have to deal with. Accepting the Father’s hospitality means that we have to share in offering it, and accept our own need of it, and our own relationship to those we might despise. And when the Father tells us, ‘everything I have is yours’, we can’t help recalling that that means not only the Father’s riches and generosity, but also his responsibilities, his grief, his suffering. It’s a tough call, at least it is for me. That’s why I come to church – so that my brothers and sisters can help me, too, to decide to come to the party, to accept the Father’s invitation.