…I suspect it’s there because she told people to put it there. She was the oldest of the children of Henry Hatch Dent who built the church in their father’s memory, and probably the mastermind of the enterprise. And on her tombstone are carved, right under the dates of her long life, the words, ‘She hath done what she could’. Those words haunt me all the time. Could they be put on my gravestone? I suppose they could, but only as a sort of feeble apology for all the things I couldn’t – you know, as in, ‘there were all these big things to be done with her life, but all she could manage were a few meager tasks…..’
Maybe ‘she has done what she could’ is a rather modest claim for anybody – it does imply that there are real limits to what a person can accomplish. The woman who comes into the scene of Jesus at dinner and shocks everyone by her extravagance in lavishing this outrageously expensive oil on Jesus before his death – how can we say that she accomplishes anything? He is about to be lynched by the local authorities – they rule with an iron hand, and from their decisions there is no appeal. There isn’t a thing she can do to save him from the death-by-torture that he’s going toward. A woman in a man’s world, a nobody (she doesn’t even have a name until John’s Gospel gives her one for its own purposes), in a world where ‘name’ is all-important; probably a Jew under the heel of the Roman boot – ‘what she could’ in a situation like that seems like nothing at all, a dramatic gesture that changes nothing, accomplishes nothing.
Certainly that’s how it has always seemed to the church. Jesus says ‘wherever this gospel is preached in the world, this story will be told in remembrance of her’ – that’s until the powers that be in the church get into the act. ‘In remembrance of her’ – the same words he uses at the last supper about the bread and wine that turn into our communion – good luck with that, Jesus. Mark tells the story and Matthew repeats it straight – but John hashes it up to mean something quite different, and Luke doesn’t tell it at all (unless you consider his story about a totally different woman, who is a ‘sinner’ and dumps the oil on Jesus’s feet instead of his head, a warped version of this one….). The church doesn’t tell it at all either if it can possibly help it – the first time this story ever appeared as a Sunday reading was in the New Common Lectionary 2000 years later. So much for ‘in remembrance of her’. And so, of course, nobody writes any hymns about her either, which is why I had to write the one we are going to sing in a few minutes.
But Jesus did say that – Jesus, at least, thought that what this woman did was worth remembering. ‘She has done a beautiful thing’, he says, in anointing him – a beautiful thing. When else do we ever hear Jesus talk about beauty? But here, on the ever of his death – a death so horrible in its sheer hideousness that we can’t even think clearly about it – here at last he calls for, and approves, something beautiful just because of its beauty. He defends it, casting aside, with his typical withering sarcasm, the phony ‘conflict’ between beauty and goodness. ‘Don’t try to tell me that this is what’s getting in the way of your doing good to the poor’, he says – ‘your chance to do that comes up every single day…..’
Jesus, you see, is the prophet of God’s Kingdom, where things aren’t hemmed in by the petty little categories that we insist on in our petty little kingdoms, so we can hang onto our illusions of control. He’s not up for the either-or method of controlling people’s thoughts or money or goodness. He would have no patience whatever with the twisted ‘reasoning’ in our modern political debates that claims that the richest nation the world has ever known ‘can’t afford’ to feed its children or keep its lands clean or teach its people the ways in which they should go. In his Kingdom, it’s never either/or; it’s always both/and. You don’t pursue one kind of goodness at the expense of another, because in his Kingdom there’s always plenty to go around, plenty to spare. In his Kingdom, when you lay yourself out for something beautiful, you’re all set up to do something good as well.
What could possibly make a person think, after hearing this story, that they could get away with theological or political or financial arguments from scarcity? – as in, ‘well, if do something beautiful (like, say, practically rebuilding this church…), then we won’t be able to do something good as well (like, say, sending a Heifer Ark to poor people around the world….). If this story isn’t enough to persuade us of how disastrous this kind of ‘reasoning’ is, surely the history of this parish ought to do the job! In all the years when this church was concentrating single-mindedly on its own welfare – and earning a reputation in this town for doing just that – it was sowing the seeds of its own destruction and death. It’s only the commitment to God’s ‘both/and’ that has brought God’s grace showering down on this place like perfumed oil running down the face of our Lord. Grace is always free – but you have to give it some place to go! If all you can think of to do with it is hang onto it, all you guarantee is the amount of grace you’ll end up with is precisely the amount you can hold in your tight little fist – and not one tiny bit more than that.
So here is our disciple, the one single person in this whole Gospel who has a clue as to what Jesus is about, on the edge of disaster, striking a blow for grace. And here is the Lord Jesus, sitting among the blockheads that he has to entrust his message to, trying one last time to get them to see the beautiful thing being done to him, and let it illuminate for them the beautiful things they could do too if they would only let go of their selfish, blind, either/or and ultimately stupid mentality that keeps both God and reality at arm’s length. In the face of that, this disciple has done what she could – she’s stood up for both beauty and truth in a situation where ugliness and lies seem to hold all the high cards. She has stood up for the overflowing abundance of God’s Kingdom in a moment when everything that matters seems about to snatched away. She has seen clearly what is around her and ahead of her, and done what was right anyway – the only one, among all the blockheads, with the courage and the imagination to see and understand the new thing that God is up to in Jesus, and pledge her allegiance to that with everything she had.
She has done what she could – only a gesture. That’s all the situation gives her any room for, but she does it. Telling the truth, giving yourself away – they seem like such small things, but, under the circumstances, maybe they are actually quite a lot. I am absolutely convinced that in this Lent, and all the time, for that matter, that’s what you and I and we are called to do – to tell the truth about who we are, where we’ve been, where we want to go, what God is telling us to do in this place and beyond it – and to give ourselves away with the kind of wild abandon, the kind of crazy liberality, that God has given of himself to us, for the sake of his Kingdom’s truth and beauty and goodness, all of them, all the time.