…Our Scriptures give us 3 takes on the question. First, Deuteronomy gives us Moses, who has led Israel out of slavery in Egypt, through the wilderness, right up to the edge of the promised land, making one last try to get the people to stay on track (which is not exactly what they have been doing for these 40 years, after all….). He has had bitter experience of how memory just ‘slips away’ from people – this group seems to have trouble remembering what happened day before yesterday – and he’s desperate to make sure that they don’t lose their connection with God entirely just out of sheer lame-brainedness. So he says, again and again, Don’t forget! You saw what God has done among you! You were there! For the plagues that defeated Pharaoh, for the crossing of the sea on dry land, for food and water in the wilderness, for constant care for everything you needed – and for the punishments when you did wrong. You saw it; don’t forget.
This is how Israel does her reasoning about right and wrong. Other cultures try to define right and wrong by abstract reasoning – Plato asks himself ‘What is the good?’. Israel goes about it from entirely the other end of things. What is good and bad is what you have experienced as good and bad. You feed people who are hungry and help those who are weak – Why? Because you have been hungry and weak and know what it feels like. You don’t oppress aliens among you – because you were aliens once yourselves. Why observe God’s laws? Because he’s the God who ransomed you from slavery! It’s all about history, not philosophy, not even, in a way, about religion – just what you have seen and heard and been told to do.
These words are easy for us to identify with. Our own history has shown us God’s care for us through all these years of rebuilding our church – which has been at some times a sort of wilderness experience. We had ways of doing things so entrenched that they were a kind of slavery; and we had no way to liberate ourselves. We had ideas about what a ‘promised land’ for us might look like, but very little idea of how to get there – and we were taken by the hand and led, and given every single thing we would need to arrive where God wanted us to be. So we can’t forget all that now that we’re on an even keel, plenty of the hard work done, plenty of money, plenty of hope for the future. Having plenty is wonderful – but it’s not very exciting. There’s nothing to worry about, so not much to be thrilled about either. We just have to settle in to the hard work of being church – with its constant temptations toward business as usual, toward boredom, toward thinking that we have to be in charge….
Those are things that encourage people to get totally off the track of doing what’s right. They forget what they’ve been commanded; they forget what they’ve been through; they can so easily slide back into doing things the old way, the easiest way, the way that doesn’t require them to remember so much. So James, speaking from the heart of the church, comes at this whole question from another angle. Why should you do right? Not just because of where you’ve been, but because of what you are. It’s in your DNA. God brought you to birth, he says, ‘by the word of truth’. This is about baptism, of course, your new birth into Jesus Christ; but it refers further back than that – back to the original creation-story in Genesis, God made us in his own image and gave us a garden to live in. James fiddles with this picture: now we are the garden. The word was planted in us, he says, and how we act is the garden’s harvest, the first fruits, the appropriate offering to the God who made it grow in the first place. And so we, the garden, also have to be gardeners – we have to tend the word planted in us and weed out the ‘rank growth of wickedness and sordidness’ among us. James brings us back to the beginnings of Israel as well – Hear, O Israel; love the Lord your God with all your heart, mind, soul, strength. Hear, which also means ‘obey’. Don’t just glance at God’s law and forget it; stare deeply into it; use it as a mirror for staring deeply into yourself; let it reveal what you are, what you’re supposed to be, what God wants of you. And don’t forget what you saw!
Which is where Jesus picks up the thread. What is it to do right, now that the history of God’s dealings with his people has gotten cloudy, now that the simplicity of Deuteronomy is no longer easy to re-capture ? What is it to be righteous? There’s the Law, written down in the centuries after Moses, and there are some second opinions – a huge body of tradition to ‘explain’ the Law, not to mention the conflicts within the Law itself. That’s what we’re dealing with today. God demands purity, cleanness – that’s clear from the Law. Terrible things happen to people who do things that make them ritually unclean – punishment, exclusion from the community, even death. But there’s another side to the Law: it’s called justice; and there’s plenty about that in there too.
And the two things, purity and justice, are so often in conflict. It’s awfully hard to fight for justice in the world if the only people you can fight for it with are the ones who are squeaky clean according to the purity standards. And if you’re out fighting the spiritual and practical battles you’re going to have to fight to establish justice, you won’t have much time left over for meeting all the purity obligations. The struggle goes on, for as long as people have been trying to follow God’s way, about whether purity or justice is what God wants most. It’s where our church has been in its conflict about homosexuality. People on one side think it’s a question of purity; those on the other side call it an issue of justice – they’re not even speaking the same language.
So here is Jesus today, on the ropes by the purity police to defend himself and his friends. How can they be from God if they don’t keep the Law that God commanded his people to keep, every single last little piece of it? How can we hope to be one of those who get to dwell in the Lord’s tabernacle, if we ignore what he told us was right and wrong? Jesus won’t answer those questions directly – but he will show us which side his church has to come down on in the struggle between purity and justice. He starts where he always starts, with who God is, a God of compassion, who reaches out to those who are by definition impure. He is the Holy One, who invites the unholy to share his fellowship. He is the creator of everything, who delights to share his power and blessedness with what he has created. His most basic attribute is mercy, the generous kindness which draws the likes of us to himself – the quality he calls ‘justice’.
In the questions of law that arise in Jesus’s teaching, his approach is always to back the question up to that point about God. Whatever the rules say, their purpose is to insure that the community that calls itself by God’s name reflects God’s mercy, God’s justice. When the community’s rules don’t reflect that, the rules have to be revised. And when there is a conflict between the rules that reflect God’s concern for justice and the ones that reflect his concern for purity, the priority is clear: justice (or mercy) trumps purity every time. And if the concern is the ritual washings that keep you from being ‘tainted’ by those ‘outsiders’ you meet in the outside world, and the ritual laws that protect your ‘pure’ insides from contamination by the unclean things outside the Law – well, if those things keep people out of the community gathered around Jesus, if they’re just obstacles to bringing people to God, then they have to go.
In fact, Jesus’s answer makes the whole ‘purity’ system look pretty silly. He points out the obvious fact that what you take in from the rest of creation goes into the mouth, down to the stomach – and on to you-know-where… We are now in the 4-letter-word area of Scripture: the image is really gross – that’s why that part is left out of today’s reading. What we eat turns into something that practically defines ‘unclean’, doesn’t it? So why get so worked up about the other end of it? But there is another intake-output system in our lives, a spiritual one. It works a little bit like the digestive system, except that you have some choice about the output – it doesn’t have to be filth. You take in the word of God (which is often described in terms of food) through the ear, it goes to the heart (or at least it’s supposed to…), and comes out of you as action. And it’s your actions that put you on God’s side or the devil’s in the ‘holy war’ that each one of us is fighting all the time. It’s your heart – your will, your spirit – that either absorbs reality with thanksgiving and reverence OR hoards it up with malice and anger and greed. It’s your heart that pushes you on towards generosity and love OR evil, fornication, theft, murder – the whole sordid list. It’s not what you take in that counts – it’s what comes out. And therefore all those foreign substances and alien people out there that once threatened you are a non-issue. The whole mentality of us vs. them, the insiders vs. the outsiders, and the thrreat that the outsiders pose to the insiders, is shot.
The choices from the heart are available to everyone, inside or outside of the Law. And the struggle to make the choices on God’s side of the balance is like war, the kind of warfare we heard about last week when we were told to put on the whole armor of God. Our model is Jesus, who refused to fight evil on its own terms and chose utter dependence on God instead. He seemingly lost the struggle for life itself when evil did its worst; but this is the same Jesus Christ who has been raised by God to new life above and beyond the struggle. His victory is God’s decisive victory in the war between him and the powers that would deform and destroy life – and because of that nothing made of flesh and blood is any more our enemy. All food is ‘pure’; all our fellow human beings are our neighbors, whom we are commanded to love. This too is history; this too is to be remembered. Don’t forget!
So we’re left to do God’s will as best we can with the commandments all written down, with the weapons of the Spirit and the fellowship of believers around us – but most of all with the experience of his abundant mercy. When it all seems like too much, when we can’t see beyond the next turn in the road, when those fellow believers drive us crazy, when we’re tempted to fear, which leads to anger, which makes us do things we might always regret, there is one remedy that won’t fail: don’t forget!