…That phony opposition is based on Paul, but an extreme and inaccurate reading of Paul, who was fighting with all his might against the idea that you had to be a Jew before you could be a Christian. Paul is emphatic about the radical nature of God’s mercy, and knows (as do the Hebrew Scriptures) that that mercy couldn’t possibly be confined to one nation, one people. Paul knows what we know, what Jews know, that whether we are under the Law or not, we are all saved by God’s grace. In Judaism the Law itself is a gracious gift, offered to us as a list of things we can do to practice the obedience we are never going to be able to do perfectly, the way a mother lets her little children ‘help’ make the cookies, so they can feel as if they can do jobs that are really beyond them. The commandments are 613 opportunities for us to practice God’s goodness right down here at our level. They spring not from some theory about what justice might be, but from bitter experience of what injustice actually is, and God’s will to rescue his people from that.
Far from being opposed to grace, the Law is what gives us a chance to respond to grace. Jew or gentile, says Paul, once you’re rescued, there are things you have to do – the transaction may begin with grace, but if it stops there, it hasn’t gotten very far. God’s people are supposed to look different from the peoples around them. That could have interesting consequencess if it were put into practice today. Just imagine if the banks in our country suddenly had to obey the commandments about loans, and were prohibited from charging any interest on them and had to refund borrowers’ collateral before the end of each day. Makes you wonder what Bible many of our nation’s leaders (who seem to believe that God invented capitalism) are reading, and what god it is they’re constantly asking to bless America. It sure isn’t the God of the Exodus, nor the Bible read in this church every week…
So when we meet the question about the Law in today’s Gospel, we are not, in short, at step 1 in the process of the Christian life. Luke loves step 1, that first moment of the encounter with grace – the little lost sheep being tenderly brought home to the fold in the arms of the shepherd, and all the violins playing…. Mt is more realistic. He knows that for sheer cussedness you can hardly beat a fold full of these little formerly-lost sheep. He knows that we don’t need another invitation to come in – we need instructions for those who already are in: how to keep the church afloat, how to live in fellowship with a Messiah who’s gone where we can’t see him, how to discern and obey laws for grownups, not spiritual babies. You can’t have community without rules, traditions, common understandings; and Mt tells us all these stories of questions, controversies, big and small issues, here at the end of Jesus’s life, to help us build those structures within which community life can take place.
We start with the essence, the heart of it all: what is the greatest commandment in the Law? In a community like Mt’s, which – like ours – has abandoned big chunks of the Law – keeping kosher, circumcision – and speaking Hebrew, how will they know that they’re still committed to God’s purposes in some way? When we’ve let go of so much that was ‘traditional’, what do we have to keep for our commitment to be genuine? What can’t we do without? It’s the right question for this last chapter of Jesus’s teaching life, and it flows immediately from last week’s question about the conflict between God and the state. According to Jesus’s remarks about Caesar’s coin, we belong to God just as the coin belongs to Caesar. As the coin is marked with his image and inscription, so we are marked with God’s. The ‘image’ part comes to us in Creation itself. Today’s reading gives us the dope on the ‘inscription’. The words Jesus quotes are supposed to be written on our arms and our foreheads, on the doorposts of our houses, before us everywhere, all the time: Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God, the Lord is one; and you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and soul and strength. The devout Jew recites this morning and evening and in between; it’s the center of what it is to be a Jew.
Jesus is telling us today that it’s also central to being a Christian, the heart of what we can’t do without from our past. A life that proposes to move God-ward is a life that has to begin with God, to make God the focus of all desire, all hope, all loyalty, all effort. Our God doesn’t want tepid commitment, half-hearted loyalty, half-baked efforts – he wants all of us. Not so that we can be absorbed, so that our selves just vanish into some vast blob of something else – we give ourselves to God so that we can become our true selves; so that we can be alive, growing, bearing fruit, becoming co-creators, with him, of the Kingdom he longs to establish in the midst of this world. Unless we love God best, most, entirely, all our other loves will be out of balance, disordered, out of their proper place – if we try to put anything else first in our lives, there will never be enough love left for God the way he desires to be loved. But the funny thing is that if we love God first and best, then there is plenty of room in our lives for the other loves that make us human.
Jesus’s choice of the second command covers it neatly – and this too is not just Jesus’s choice, but something the rabbis have been saying, and will keep on saying for centuries more. We are to love our neighbors not up to some abstract standard, but as simply as we love ourselves. We don’t love ourselves abstractly, but in the flesh, in actual-ity; we show the love in practical terms: we don’t abuse ourselves; we don’t seek to hurt ourselves; we aren’t glad when we see ourselves going wrong; we don’t enjoy finding fault with ourselves; we try to keep ourselves out of trouble; we try at all times to meet our own needs, even trivial wants….. Doesn’t this sound like a plan? In this church that does a pretty good job of looking out for each other, are there ways we can love our neighbors better than we already do? When we speak to each other do we seek to build each other up or tear each other down? When there is something wrong in our common life, do we seek out its cause with eagerness to mend the wrong, or with glee that we can find someone to blame for it? The dangers are many, even in church. How often is what we say or do shaped not by the Holy Spirit toward compassion and a delight in the right ordering of things, but a spirit of self-righteousness and delight in catching others out in some fault? Such a spirit has no place among those who are loved by a compas-sionate God. Being the friend of Emmanuel, the savior of human frailty, can’t possibly co-exist with being the ally of Satan, the Accuser.
There isn’t one of us in this room who would rejoice in being caught out in wrong, blamed, made fun of, made to look foolish or incompetent – not one who would enjoy being excluded, demeaned, left out, uninvited; not one who longs to hear another person say, ‘It’s all your fault’, or ‘I’m not interested in you’ or ‘you’re so dumb’ or ‘there’s no place for you in this project’. Doesn’t that give us all the guidance we need in how to relate to our brothers and sisters? This congregation should shine with the welcome and encouragement and hopefulness that radiate from the face of God towards us; there is no place in it for the negativity, or salvation as competitive sport, that marks the life of the unredeemed world around us.
But in that world are neighbors too, people who have claims on us not because they are nice or successful or authoritative, simply because, like us, they are God’s. Our call as Christians is a call to radical hospitality – there could hardly be a better definition of what the command to love neighbors as ourselves entails. The problem is that such hospitality involves risk, and we live in a society that is obsessed with safety, with creating a risk-free world, in which all possible contingencies have been thought of and protected against. What can you say against safety, after all? What’s wrong with protecting ourselves against what we know could hurt us? If you don’t know the answer to that, I refer you to the rabbi again – not what he says, today, but what he is doing – heading for the ultimate risk, a death that you and I would cringe to talk about, a death inflicted on him by people who were terrified of the radical hospitality he offered to those that represented, to the system he lived within, a radical risk. There’s room for discernment among Christians about what kind of risks we can or must expose ourselves to in his project of hospitality – but there is no room at all in Jesus’s church for blind acceptance of our culture’s obsession with protecting itself, at any cost, from what it fears.
If the strange sequel to the great commandments – the second half of the Gospel lesson – means anything at all for us today, it must be that the Messiah, the son of the great warrior-king David, is more powerful, more authoritative, more effective in dealing with the things that terrify us, than any warrior, or any solution based on war against what we fear. If we indeed love God with all that we are, it is only because this God has loved all that we are first; and within the love of that God for us, what could we possibly fear enough to transgress his commands for? What could possibly justify our classifying some brother or sister, some circumstance, some expense, as too scary to welcome for his sake? What risk could possibly put us outside of his love?